Top 10: David Bowie

By Peter Guy on Jan 8, 13 04:15 PM in The Top 10

David Bowie returned with new single Where Are We Now? today - his first material since 2003. Getintothis' Alison Gow was one of millions rather excited about the news. When she'd returned to earth we asked her to compile her top ten - no easy task for this super fan who danced to one of his songs at her wedding...

The 8.30am news on Radio Wales is, generally, a quick run through some developments Welsh politics, some Afghanistan-related tragedy, and traffic woes.

On Tuesday January 8, however, the final item (after, indeed, the news of a British soldier being shot dead in Helmund) was a stunner.

David Bowie had released a single. With an album to follow. DAVID. BOWIE. My David, the man who fell to my particular patch of nine-year-old Earth and revolutionised my music world with Scary Monsters and Super Creeps. (Note: Said revolution was not difficult, given that same summer brought horror in the form of the Gap Band's Oops Upside Your Head and Leo Sayer's More Than I Can Say).

After a 10-year hiatus, and a no-show at the 2012 Olympic Opening Ceremony that dashed fans' hopes of a live performance, he's back to mark his 66th birthday with a single, Where Are We Now? to be followed by his 30th studio recording, The Next Day.


Awash with personal references, melancholy abounds in the new single - Bowie sings of "a man lost in time", stalking hauntedly through Berlin streets "just walking the dead" but towards the end hope soars "as long as there's you, as long as there's me".

It is unutterably moving, even allowing for the fact the video features a Bowie character with an uncanny resemblance to the Bo! Selecta Bear, and reminiscent of Seven, from the album Heathen.

As you'd expect, when Twitter heard of the new single, it exploded. Just about every national newspaper website has dusted off it's Bowie biog and cobbled together some thoughts about What It All Means with an eye to linkbait and comment.

What it means, quite simply, is that a singer who defies convention and description (although well done Guardian for attempting it with the term 'Glam rock singer') is still telling his stories through the medium of music and imagery.

This isn't a reinvention, it's a performance. Whether it's Cockney Troubador (London Boy) Apocalyptic Saviour (Ziggy Stardust), Nihilist (Berlin period), drum n bass (Earthling) or blond pop star (Let's Dance) Bowie is a deck of cards, and you just have to play the hand he deals you.

So, let's turn over the cards he placed - in no particular order - on my piece of green baize, shall we?


1. Station to Station: from Station to Station (1976)
Otherwise known as Bowie - The Cocaine Years, the album includes the magnificent Golden Years, and bizarre TVC 15, about a girlfriend being eaten by a television set.

But for me the standout is the eponymous opening track, with it's sense of impending disaster; the slow build of synthesised train tracks emerging from the vinyl crackle, the agonized wail of strings, the maddening, repetative 'dum, dum, dum, dum' beat, then...nothing...

Followed by Bowie informing us of "The return of the Thin White Duke, throwing darts in lovers' eyes". Scary, wonderful, compelling.

2. Cygnet Committee - from Space Oddity (1969)

Despite Space Oddity sounding naive and folky, it's actually Bowie at his most cynical, tapping directly into what was commercially attractive to get his sounds out.

Opening with Space Oddity, it swings between flashes of brilliance-to-come (Letter to Hermoine) and cludgy social consciousness (God Knows I'm Good). Janine is probably the most accessible track but Cygnet Committee has always been my favourite.

To me, it tells of a parasitic relationship between a guru and followers - it's properly Anti Christ in its cynicism ('We used him, we let him use his powers - we let him fill our needs'), and I can see how the leap from that to the Messianic Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust was a natural step.

3. Survive - from Hours (2003)

Critically acclaimed, panned by most fans, this is a problematic album for me.

Lyrically it's beautiful, and some of the tracks soar, but in this case the sum just isn't greater than the whole of the parts.

Having said that, Survive is one of the most gorgeous, memorable songs in the Bowie canon - guitarist Reeves Gabrels is nothing short of astonishing; the heartbreaking beauty of the lyrics - "I should have kept you, I should have tried"... "You're the great mistake I never made" and the optimism of the repeated refrain "I'll survive". It's unforgettable.


4. Panic In Detroit - from Aladdin Sane (1973)

Picking just one song from Aladdin Sane is hard - it does, after all, include the tracks Jean Genie and Life on Mars, but Panic In Detroit is a standout that defies time and is as relevant today as then.

It's a bleak look a the (short) life of a revolutionary - I believe it's loosely based on discussions with Iggy Pop - and features Mick Ronson in the form of his life.

Raw, thundering and angry. Reading the Stephen King novella, Apt Pupil, years later it struck me - is what Bowie's young protagonist grew up to become.

5. Rock n Roll With Me - from Diamond Dogs (1974)

After the Ziggy phase came a vision of post-Apocalyptic hell where "fleas the size of rats sucked on rats the size of cats".

As a kid, everything about this album unsettled me, including the cover art. As a teen, I read 1984 and everything made sense. 'When you rock and roll with me' is a small glint of hope in a world gone to hell.

It's the song I danced to at my wedding. That's it, really.

6. Jump, They Say - from Black Tie, White Noise (1993)

Here is Bowie's mentally-ill half-brother, Terry, once more. Terry haunts the Man Who Sold the World - far more, for me, than Aladdin Sane - but this track, from a few decades later, is horribly gripping because of the role onlookers play - urging a suicidal person to take that step into the ether and oblivion.

The track has a jazzy, discordant feel that (to me, anyway) speaks of the would-be jumper's suffering - it's itchy, twitchy, and deeply uncomfortable, but it works perfectly.

7. Yassassin - from Lodger (1979)

Poppy and jangly, this is a bit at odds with Lodger - the most accessible of the Berlin trilogy in my mind.

I just checked the release date on Wikipedia, to discover Lodger is "more accessible than its immediate predecessors Low and Heroes" so, there you go. I must be right.

Other than the fact that Yassassin is Turkish for 'long life', I can't exactly explain why this is one of the best songs on the album apart from - you have to dance to it. YOU HAVE TO.

8. New Killer Star - from Reality (2003)

The first single off an album that is one of my favourites (auto skip on Pablo Picasso, if I'm honest) it sits alongside Survive for me as a sublime musical piece that uplifts, despite the apparent post 9/11 subject matter.

Gerry Leonard is astonishing on the guitar (he uses an ebow). It's a track to drive fast to and forget that it doesn't necessarily make a lot of lyrical sense.

9. Sons of the Silent Age - Heroes (1979)

They 'stand on platforms, blank looks and note books'.

For me, they are T. S Elliot's Hollow Men - striving and failing, frightening and pathetic.

The optimistic, 'baby, baby, baby' of the chorus just throws the passivity of the Sons into sharp relief. Their world really does end with a whimper, rather than a bang.

10. Rock n Roll Suicide from The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust... (1972)

The album's closing track and a single - an odd choice given the treasures RCA had to chose from.

The opening lyrics - that first drag of a cigarette - are incredibly visual; you can almost see the smoke ring.

It's post-career Ziggy, when all has gone to ashes, but when listened to in context of the entire album it's a rising up - a return to give hope and encouragement, and a beautiful counterpoint to the opening despair of Five Years.

Rock n Roll Suicide is a howl although I think it's one where anguish becomes defiance, and it (to me) it's a massive double eagle to the world.
I love it.


David Prentice said:

SO what if I’m a day late? David kept us waiting 10 years.
While I can’t claim the same level of fan devotion as Alison (she
includes loads of stuff AFTER Scary Monsters for heaven’s sake!)
Bowie’s always been my man.
So in no particular order, here’s My Top 10.

1. Soul Love.

IT'S the track no-one ever mentions on Ziggy Stardust. Yet it's one of
the best on even that masterpiece of an album.
Lyrically it's Bowie at his most angst ridden

Stone love - she kneels before the grave
A brave son - who gave his life
To save the slogans
That hovers between the headstone and her eyes
For they penetrate her grieving

But while the words could be offered up to study for A Level English
students, musically it soars, moves and inspires. And coming after the
apocalyptic opening of Five Years it even offers hope.

2. Kooks

To small Z.
Silly musings on parenthood it may be, but Kooks bounces along like
the happy, carefree child it sends a message to.
While Hunky Dory contained the poignant perfection of Life on Mars,
the reflective Quicksand and the cathartic Bewlay Brothers, it also
has two of the happiest songs he's ever written. Fill Your Heart is a
joyous lust for life, but it's Kooks which always leaves you with a
smile on your face.

3. Always Crashing In the Same Car

Let's be fair, you could make a top 10 from the entire Low album.
Actually make that top 11 because you couldn't justifiably leave anything out.
But it's the suicidal Always Crashing which gets the nod on this list.
Just. From Be My Wife, and maybe Sound and Vision. And of course A New
Career In A New Town. And Art Decade. Oh bugger. This is harder than I

4. Teenage Wildlife

Scary Monster's was Bowie's last truly great album. (Don’t shoot me.
It’s all personal opinion! And I do like Hours and Heathen). The great
slabs of techno funk which drive Fashion would be the obvious choice,
while the title track is rip-roaring madness and I love the
undisguised cockneyness of the line “Well I love the little girl and
I’ll love her till the day she dies.” But it's the Bruce Springsteen
pastiche Teenage Wildlife which gets the nod.

5. Stay
Carlos Alomar's classic riff in the funkiest of Bowie's funky songs. I
used to have a Christiane F. soundtrack where a scratch meant Stay
jumped just at the end and repeated that riff over and over again. I
never got up to nudge it because it was that good.

6. 1984.
Another funky classic which pre-dated Stay by a couple of years and
maybe showed the direction Bowie was headed on his next album, Young
Americans. 1984 combines apocalyptic madness with great guitar work.
And yes it does sound a bit like Isaac Hayes’ Shaft which is no bad

7. Lady Grinning Soul.

Tinkling piano chords, moving lyrics and Bowie's voice at its most
haunting. How can you possibly follow Ziggy Stardust? Bowie did, and
this track is one of my favourites from an under-rated album.

8. God Knows I’m Good

The only track I know that contains the lyric “Tin of stewing steak.”
without sounding silly.
It's a sad, pathetic tale of shoplifting, with heart-rending pleas
from a little old lady. But it's also intensely moving.

9. John I'm Only Dancing

The original version, not the '76 one, which featured on the Changes album.
Funny and funky and poppy . . . and banned in the USA because a joke
about a homsexual relationship was considered too risque for the
America’s moral majority.
Their loss.
According to Wikipedia a later “sax version” is “generally held to
be superior to the original cut,” while there was yet another
completely reworked funk-influenced version recorded as “John, I’m
Only Dancing (Again).”
He needn’t have bothered. The original is great.

10. Heroes.

Alright, I've tried to steer clear of the obvious choices. So no Jean
Genie, Life On Mars, Rebel Rebel or Wild Is The Wind. Or Modern Love.
Because it was crap.
But you can't leave Heroes out of any list. Even hearing it a hundred
times during the Olympic Games couldn't dull its heart-lifting
majesty, its awesomeness and its celebratory, life-affirming
Even in German it sounds wonderful.
Und wir sind dann Helden. Für einen Tag.

Leave a comment

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

This is to help prevent spamming and confirm you are a human


Getintothis Blogger

Peter Guy

Peter Guy

is at the forefront of Liverpool's independent music scene reporting & reviewing on the latest sounds in Merseyside and beyond.
Read My Posts »

Follow Us on Twitter

Liverpool's GIT Music Award


With a collection to rival a small record shop and a gig diary fit for any addled groupie, music is Peter Guy's religion. Working alongside the key players across Merseyside and the national music scene, Peter has edited the official Liverpool Sound City magazine The Liberator, been a media partner with Liverpool Music Week and covered festivals and industry showcases home and abroad. Getintothis is his irreverent insider's guide to Liverpool's music landscape and beyond.

My Last.Fm